eXtreme Programming Versus Scrum

extreme programming versus scrumSo you’ve had enough of failed projects. You like the sound of agile development as an alternative. You buy into the key principles and you’re ready to take the plunge.

Which methodology should you go for?

I don’t have any official stats on which agile methodologies are most widely used, but there certainly seems to be much more of a buzz about eXtreme Programming and Scrum, at least on a global basis.

So which is right for you, eXtreme Programming (XP) or Scrum?

I’ve heard people ask this question. I’ve heard people talk about them as though they are mutually exclusive choices. But really they are not.

eXtreme Programming and Scrum are so different they are not really comparable.

They share the same underlying values described in the agile manifesto, and the same underlying principles that characterise ‘agile’. They overlap in areas, but fundamentally they address completely different aspects of agile software development.

Scrum is an agile management methodology. Whereas XP is an agile engineering methodology. As such they are entirely complementary.

If your motivation for agile is wanting more visibility, better business engagement, team collaboration, a clear process for prioritisation, etc – Scrum is for you.

In both cases you will benefit from a more incremental, iterative approach to development.

In my experience, Scrum is the more likely starting point when the adoption of agile is driven by management. XP is the more likely starting point when the adoption of agile is driven by developers.

In my view? Ideally you would do both. Or at least elements of both. And you would start with the one that addresses the issues causing you to adopt agile in the first place.

Kelly.

Photo by i-plus

15 Responses to “eXtreme Programming Versus Scrum”

  1. axe says:

    Kelly,

    but how we can do good agile only with agile management without agile engineering?

    It’s seems dubiously :(

  2. Kelly Waters says:

    Hi Axe

    In my post, I suggested that ideally you need to do both, because they address different aspects of software development, i.e. Scrum for management, XP for engineering.

    It is possible to achieve acceptable product quality without XP, although XP I believe would raise the quality.

    Therefore, if quality is not an problem area, you can achieve very good benefits from Scrum (i.e. agile management) or other agile management methods. XP, whilst very good, is optional and not a pre-requisite for good agile performance.

    Regards
    Kelly.

  3. axe says:

    Oh, sorry, my previous comment wasn’t enough applicable :(

    You are right.

  4. Franck says:

    We could also ask the opposite question: “how we can do good agile only with agile engineering without agile management ?” ;o)

  5. Anonymous says:

    Your article is very hard to read with the ubiquitous use of bold, underlines and blue-but-it-isn’t-a-link.
    At a glance, it looks more like a tag cloud than a blog post.
    I diddn’t bother reading i for that reason, so I cannot comment on the contents of the article.

  6. Kelly Waters says:

    Thanks to Anonymous for the feedback above.

    I started doing the bold thing a while back, in order to make it quicker for people to skim read my entries and still get the key points. Perhaps I have over-done it.

    I would be grateful for any other feedback on this, so I can make my blog better for everyone going forward.

    Does it help or does it hinder?

    Kelly.

  7. Dantelope says:

    I have read two blog entries now and both invited the same reaction sequence:

    1) “Whaaa?” — Your titles/intros are often the inverse of what you are trying to say and serve to incite. While that may make for “exciting reading” to you, it infuriates your readers (me at least).

    2) “Ohhhh” — It comes out that you are trying to say something other than what your title/intro suggests.

    3) “I agree” — I typically agree with your main argument. Especially in this post. XP vs. Scrum is moronic comparison by people who haven’t bothered to understand what either is before they try to compare them.

    4) “That sucked” — Because of the shortness of your articles, the ubiquitous and annoying use of bold/blue (not a link… very troubling), and the inverted argument, I am left both times feeling negative about the article even though I agreed with it.

    So in response to “Does it help or does it hinder?” — it definitely hinders, but it’s not the only thing holding you back.

    LOVE the content, but HATE the format.

  8. Kelly Waters says:

    Thanks to Dantelope for the feedback. Despite the criticism, I’m really pleased to hear it and it will help me to improve my blog.

    More please :-)

    Many thanks

    Kelly.

  9. Anonymous says:

    I like the highlighting. :)

  10. Anonymous says:

    Bold helps stress the points and I like that.

  11. DatNt says:

    I like the way you apply Bold to the font in the document. Very useful.

    DatNT

  12. Jude says:

    Scrum + XP is a good combination. I am looking at adopting it for my company. How does scrum address product release process. I see it as more focussed toward delivery rather than on release and maintenance

  13. Anonymous says:

    i think its dumb that people commented on the formatting structure.. frankly who cares its the information that counts ..

    u really broke up the meaning of the words in simple terms for me, I found it easier to comprehend the meaning behind both methods

  14. isak.swahn says:

    The boldness works fine with me – it gives a sense of the writer "speaking" directly to me, putting her emphasis on the words that are important, just like an inspiring lecturer would do.

    The taste is different, and it's not possible to accommodate everyone. The first person who complained said he didn't even read the article, so I guess he went on to find a different article on the subject. This means he didn't suffer from this style either. :-)

  15. wic says:

    I don't think it is fair to say that XP is more an engineering practice than Scrum. Scrum is more like a subset of XP, which means that XP contains at least the same amount of project management practices as Scrum. More info here:

    http://www.objectmentor.com/omSolutions/agile_xp_differences.html

Leave a Reply

What is 6 + 2 ?
Please leave these two fields as-is:
Please do this simple sum so I know you are human:)

There are 101 ways to approach anything.
To find the best way, sometimes you need expert help

What People Say

“Kelly revolutionised the way our digital department operated. A true advocate of agile principles, he quickly improved internal communication within our teams and our internal clients by aligning our business and creating a much enhanced sense of transparency in the decisions the business was making. Kelly also introduced a higher sense of empowerment to the development teams...”

PETER SILVA-JANKOWSKI
IPC MEDIA

“Kelly’s a leading program director with the ability to take charge from day one and keep strong momentum at both a program and project level driving prioritisation, resourcing and budgeting agendas. Kelly operates with an easy-going style and possesses a strong facilitation skill set. From my 5 months experience working with Kelly, I would recommend Kelly to program manage large scale, complex, cross company change programs both from a business and IT perspective.”

LUKE SHARKEY /STRATEGY & IMPLEMENTATION LEADER
SUNCORP

“Kelly is an extremely talented and visionary leader. As such he manages to inspire all around him to achieve their best. He is passionate about agile and has a wealth of experience to bring to bear in this area. If you're 'lucky' he might even tell you all about his agile blog. Above all this, Kelly is great fun to work with. He is always relaxed and never gets stressed - and trust me, he had plenty of opportunity here! If you get the chance to work with Kelly, don't pass it up.”

GILES BENTLEY, DEVELOPMENT & OPERATIONS DIRECTOR
TIME INC

“Kelly is an Agile heavy-weight. He came in to assess my multi-million $ Agile development program which wasn’t delivering the right throughput. He interviewed most of the team and made some key recommendations that, when implemented, showed immediate results. I couldn’t ask for more than that except he’s a really nice guy as well.”

DAN PULHAM, DIGITAL DIRECTOR
TELSTRA

“Kelly and I worked together on a very large project trying to secure a new Insurer client. Kelly had fantastic commercial awareness as well as his technical expertise. Without him I would never had secured this client so I owe a lot to him. He is also a really great guy!”

GINA MILLARD
GLASS'S INFORMATION SERVICES

“Kelly came to the department and has really made a huge impact on how the department communicates, collaborates and generally gets things done. We were already developing in an agile way, but Kelly has brought us even more into alignment with agile and scrum best practices, being eager to share information and willing to work with us to change our processes rather than dictate how things must be done. He is highly knowledgable about agile development (as his active blog proves) but his blog won't show what a friendly and knowledgeable guy he is. I highly recommend Kelly to anyone looking for a CTO or a seminar on agile/scrum practices - you won't be disappointed!”

ANDY JEFFRIES/TECHNICAL LEAD
IPC MEDIA

“Kelly was a great colleague to work with - highly competent, trustworthy and generally a nice bloke.”

HANNAH JOYCE
GLASS'S INFORMATION SERVICES

“Kelly was engaged as a Program Director on a complex business and technology transformation program for Suncorp Commercial Insurance. Kelly drew on his key capabilities and depth of experience to bring together disparate parties in a harmonised way, ensuring the initiate and concept phases of the program were understood and well formulated. Excellent outcome in a very short time frame. ”

BRUCE WEIR/EGM
SUNCORP

“I worked with Kelly on many projects at IPC and I was always impressed with his approach to all of them, always ensuring the most commercially viable route was taken. He is great at managing relationships and it was always a pleasure working with him.”

BEATRIZ MONTOYA/CONSUMER MARKETING DIRECTOR
IPC MEDIA

“I worked with Kelly whilst at Thoughtworks and found him to be a most inspiring individual, his common-sense approach coupled with a deep understanding of Agile and business makes him an invaluable asset to any organisation. I can't recommend Kelly enough.”

PETER THATCHER, SENIOR ACCOUNT DIRECTOR
ThoughtWorks

“Kelly was a brilliant CTO and a great support to me in the time we worked together. I owe Kelly a great deal in terms of direction and how to get things done under sometimes difficult circumstances. Thanks Kelly.”

JULIE PEEL
GLASS'S INFORMATION SERVICES